DCMA 14-Point Schedule Check vs. Construction Scheduling Reality: What Planners Must Know & An Expert’s Perspective

Description:

As a project scheduler, I’ve often come across a recurring question: Should every construction schedule be forced to pass the DCMA 14-Point check?

On paper, the Defense Contract Management Agency’s 14-Point Schedule Assessment is a solid framework. It helps evaluate the technical health of a schedule — making sure logic is sound, links are clear, and durations are reasonable. In theory, it’s a great quality gate.

But here’s the truth: construction isn’t theory. It’s messy, unpredictable, and influenced by everything from weather delays to late approvals and site conditions. Forcing construction schedules to fit neatly into the DCMA template can sometimes do more harm than good.

What the DCMA 14-Point Check Covers:

The DCMA’s checklist was originally built for defense contracts, but today it’s widely applied in project scheduling. It tests:

Limits on constraints and lags
No open ends in the network
A clear critical path
Caps on float and activity durations
No negative float
High logic density

It’s a useful tool. But the challenge comes when we apply these rigid rules to construction scheduling, where reality doesn’t always match the math.

Where Construction Schedules Push Back:

Constraints Aren’t “Bad” — They’re Reality

Permits, approvals, and weather windows are real. Removing them just to pass a check creates a “perfect” schedule that ignores actual risks.

Lags Reflect Site Logic

Concrete curing, inspections, mobilization — these can’t be squeezed into fake activities. Lags are sometimes the most honest way to show dependencies.

Not Every Open End is Wrong

External deliverables or placeholders happen. Forcing artificial links just to close open ends adds noise, not clarity.

Critical Path is Dynamic

On a construction site, the critical path shifts constantly. Passing a test doesn’t guarantee it matches what crews are actually battling day to day.

Float Isn’t the Enemy

Large float values are normal in phased construction. Artificially cutting float doesn’t make the project more urgent — it makes the data less truthful.

Negative Float Tells a Story

It signals real delays and risks. Hiding it creates false optimism and masks accountability.

Long Durations Can Be Necessary

Procurement packages or deep foundations often exceed 44 days. Breaking them down just to tick a box adds admin effort, not project value.

Too Many Links = Clutter

Construction often works in work packages. Over-linking every single task makes the schedule heavy, complex, and harder for teams to follow.

The Ground Truth:

At the end of the day, a construction schedule isn’t about “passing” an audit. It’s about helping the project team succeed.

Field teams don’t ask if the float is capped at 44 days. They ask:

What’s next week’s plan?
Where are the bottlenecks?
Do we have enough resources?
What risks should we prepare for?

That’s why good schedulers balance both worlds. We respect the DCMA’s logic checks — but we don’t lose sight of what the site really needs: clarity, accuracy, and transparency.

Conclusion & Lessons Learned

The DCMA 14-Point check is a strong tool for measuring schedule quality, but it was never meant to replace professional judgment. In construction, realism beats perfection.

A schedule that passes every DCMA test may look good in a report — but if it hides constraints, ignores delays, or overcomplicates the logic, it won’t help deliver the project.

As planners, our goal should always be this:

Build schedules that tell the truth, support decision-making, and drive successful outcomes.

Because at the end of the day, projects aren’t delivered by passing a test — they’re delivered by teams on the ground.

Discussions

ADDITIONAL RESOURCES

For a comprehensive understanding, we recommend exploring our dedicated tutorials on Primavera P6 relationships. These tutorials are accessible through our Planning P6 Tutorials Dictionary (REV-003). Simply search for keywords like “relationship” or “Primavera P6 integration” to access relevant content.